I watched Dallas Buyers Club at the weekend and I watched with high expectations. I must admit, that these expectations were met and I really liked the film. However, I didn't enjoy it for the reasons that I thought I would. After watching The Oscars, I felt really irritated that the lovely Leo didn't win the Oscar for best actor in his recent film The Wolf Of Wall Street. I felt even more irritated after seeing Matthew McConaughey's speech about how he is his own hero (arrogant much?) But then I realised that I was perhaps just bieng biased because I am 100% in love with Leo and I hadnt actually seen Dallas Buyers Club at this point so I couldn't really say that McConaughey didn't deserve the Oscar. I needed cold, hard proof.
So I watched the film. I genuinely wanted to come away from it feeling like I was wrong and that McConaughey did genuinely deserve the Oscar. However, after half an hour of watching, I thought that McConaughey's acting and character depiction didn't really seem very different to the style he has adopted before. Don't get me wrong, I love Matthew McConaughey. Put How To Lose A Guy In 10 Days in the DVD player, bring me a bottle of wine and some popcorn and I'm yours; and I must admit it was nice to see him in a film where he isn't taking his shirt off every five seconds. Despite all this, I still was questioning whether or not his performance in Dallas Buyers Club was Oscar worthy. I don't think it was.
However, after watching two minutes of his co-star, Jared Leto, I was 100% convinced that Leto fully deserved his Oscar (despite my love for Jonah Hill's portrayal of Donnie Azoff in Wolf of Wall Street.) I hadnt seen the trailer for Dallas Buyers Club, so I had no idea that Leto would pop up as a transvestite - and a rather attractive one at that. Once I realised the character was being played by Leto I was impressed. McConaughey's performance when compared to Leto's lacked depth and insight.
I'm not saying that McConaughey's performance wasn't powerful because it really was. One of the most moving scenes in the film for me was a scene in the supermarket where Ron Woodroof (McConaughey) makes his homophobic 'friend' shake Rayon's (Leto's) hand. This depiction of Ron's transition from a homophobe to a defender of his gay friend sends an important message to the audience. The relationship that exists and develops between Ron and Rayon comes to be one of mutual respect of one anothers sexuality. When Ron contracts the HIV virus, he is verbally abused by his former friends because they assume that he is a homosexual and that is how he acquired the virus. This ignorance from his peers forces Ron into the shoes of homosexuals and he is forced to endure the same abuse that they receive.
Although this film has a strong story and portrays messages that all should respect, I still believe that McConaughey's performance was perhaps not as deserved of an Oscar as much as everyone thinks it is. I must say that I though his performance in the Lincoln Lawyer oushines that of his performance in Dallas Buyers Club. Sorry Matt.

